🇺🇸 New York to Reykjavik 🇮🇸 NYC · Iceland

The usual fare is about US$850. The cheapest fare we logged was US$412 roundtrip. 2 deals in the last year, a median 51% under the usual price. Price the pair now:

Live fares from the airlines, one per carrier · a verdict against the usual price · set an alert on any result · or
US$850usual fare on this pair
US$412cheapest we logged · 2026-11-02
2deals in a year · 1 nonstop
-51%median saving when we posted

When it was cheapest

US$412November 2026

Live now on this pair

🇮🇸 New York → ReykjavikUS$426 · -50%

Every deal we posted

US$426 roundtripposted 2026-11-13 · live now-50%usual US$850US$412 roundtripposted 2026-11-02 · nonstop · travel Nov 2026 – Feb 2027 · expired-52%usual US$850

Questions

What is a cheap flight from New York to Reykjavik?

The usual fare is about US$850; anything well under that is a deal. The best fare we logged in the last year was US$412 roundtrip, posted 2026-11-02. Across 2 deals the median saving was 51%.

When is it cheapest to fly New York to Reykjavik?

The deals we posted were cheapest in November 2026 (US$412). Fares move; the search above prices any date now, and an alert tells you when one drops.

Are there nonstop deals from New York to Reykjavik?

1 of the 2 deals we posted were nonstop.

How do I get told about the next one?

Search the pair above and press the alert button under the verdict, or join the free Telegram channel: every verified deal lands there the moment it passes the price check.

More

✈️ All deals from New York📍 Cheap flights to Reykjavik🗺️ Map from New York